When Markets Hit Highs But Fear Hits Lows: What 43 Days of Chaos Taught Us

In partnership with

The Paradox at the Market's Peak

There's something deeply unusual happening in markets right now. On Wednesday, November 13, the Dow Jones Industrial Average closed above 48,000 for the first time in history. The S&P 500 sits near 6,850, notching fresh record highs. Yet beneath this seemingly triumphant surface, the CNN Fear & Greed Index registered a reading of just 21—signaling "extreme fear" among investors. The VIX volatility gauge spiked above 21, its highest level in weeks.

How can markets be simultaneously euphoric and terrified? The answer lies in the extraordinary 43 days we just lived through—and the profound uncertainty still ahead.

After the longest government shutdown in American history officially ended late Wednesday night, investors are now confronting a reality where:

• Economic policymaking has become dangerously unpredictable

• Critical data may be permanently lost

• The Federal Reserve is more divided than it's been in years

This week's market action tells the story in stark terms:

• Tech stocks crashed early in the week, with the Nasdaq plunging 3% in what felt like a violent rotation away from AI darlings

• By Wednesday, those losses had largely reversed as news of the shutdown's end sparked relief buying

• The whipsaw moves, elevated volatility, and extreme fear reading all point to the same conclusion: investors have no idea what comes next

For systematic investors who rely on rules-based strategies and disciplined rebalancing, this environment demands extra vigilance.

Find your customers on Roku this Black Friday

As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.

Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.

Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

The 43-Day Data Blackout That Changed Everything

Let's start with what just happened—because its implications will ripple through markets for months to come. The federal government shutdown that began October 1 didn't just furlough 670,000 workers or disrupt 42 million families receiving food assistance. It created something far more insidious for investors: a complete economic data blackout at a critical inflection point.

The stakes are sobering:

• October jobs report? May never be released

• October Consumer Price Index? Same story

• White House Press Secretary confirmed Wednesday these reports could be permanently lost, stating that Democrats "may have permanently damaged the Federal Statistical system"

For the first time in modern history, we may have permanent gaps in the economic data series that markets rely on to make trillion-dollar allocation decisions.

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell acknowledged the bind this creates. At his October 29 press conference, he admitted the Fed would be "flying blind" for the December policy meeting, forced to rely on private-sector data like ADP's employment figures rather than the comprehensive government reports that normally guide monetary policy.

The economic cost extends beyond data:

• The Congressional Budget Office estimates the shutdown could shave 1.5 to 2 percentage points from fourth-quarter GDP growth

• Flight cancellations reached 10% at major airports as air traffic controllers worked without pay

• Consumer confidence fell to six-month lows

The message to markets was unmistakable: Washington dysfunction has reached levels that create real economic damage, not just political theater.

The funding bill signed Wednesday only extends through January 30, meaning we could be right back here in ten weeks. That's not a prediction—it's the stated timeline. Markets hate uncertainty, but this is something worse: certainty that more uncertainty is coming.

The Fed's Impossible Tightrope Just Got Narrower

Against this chaotic backdrop, the Federal Reserve finds itself in an unenviable position. At its October meeting, the FOMC cut rates by 0.25 percentage points to a range of 3.75% to 4%—the second cut this year. But immediately after announcing the decision, Chair Powell threw cold water on expectations for a December follow-up.

"There were strongly differing views on how to proceed in December," Powell told reporters, adding that another rate cut at the next meeting "isn't a foregone conclusion. Far from it."

The contrast with the Fed's earlier messaging was stark:

• Just weeks ago, markets had priced in a near-certainty of December easing

• After Powell's comments, those odds collapsed to 67%

The internal division within the FOMC has become impossible to ignore:

• Governor Stephen Miran has dissented at multiple meetings, arguing for more aggressive 0.50-percentage-point cuts to support a labor market he sees as weakening rapidly

• Kansas City Fed President Jeffrey Schmid dissented in the opposite direction at October's meeting, preferring no cut at all

This is not the typical choreographed consensus the Fed prefers to project.

The fundamental problem is straightforward but brutally difficult to solve:

• Inflation remains at 3% on an annual basis—50% above the Fed's 2% target

• Core inflation sits even higher at 3.1%

• Yet ADP's October data showed private employers shedding an average of 11,250 jobs per week—a striking reversal

The Fed's dual mandate—maximum employment and stable prices—is pulling in opposite directions.

The shutdown only amplified these tensions. Without official jobs reports and inflation data, Fed officials are reduced to making educated guesses about the economy's true trajectory. More hawkish members can point to sticky inflation and argue for patience. More dovish voices can highlight labor market weakness and push for faster cuts. Neither side has the hard data to definitively prove their case.

It's monetary policy by instinct, at precisely the moment when precision matters most.

When All-Time Highs Meet Extreme Fear

Here's where things get genuinely interesting from a contrarian perspective. Despite the shutdown chaos, Fed uncertainty, and persistent inflation concerns, major U.S. stock indexes are at or near all-time highs:

• The Dow's breakthrough above 48,000 marked its seventh new closing high this month

• The S&P 500 has posted 36 record closes in 2025 alone

Yet investor sentiment tells a completely different story. The CNN Fear & Greed Index registered just 21 on November 10—deep in "extreme fear" territory, comparable to readings typically seen during genuine market crashes or crisis periods.

This disconnect creates what market historians would call a sentiment anomaly:

• Normally, extreme fear coincides with falling prices—think March 2020 when both sentiment and the S&P 500 collapsed together

• Extreme greed usually appears near market peaks, right before corrections

• But extreme fear at all-time highs? That's rare

What we're witnessing is a market that's technically strong but emotionally fragile:

The positive drivers:

• Strong corporate earnings: Q3 saw 82% of S&P 500 companies beat estimates, with earnings growth of 14.6% (best since 2021)

• Ongoing enthusiasm around artificial intelligence

• Few attractive alternatives when cash yields are falling and bonds remain unappealing

The anxiety underneath:

• The VIX spiking above 21—while not catastrophic—indicates options traders are paying elevated premiums for downside protection

• Only six of eleven S&P 500 sectors finished positive in October

• Market gains depend on a handful of companies—Nvidia, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Meta

This narrowness itself breeds fear. When market gains depend on a handful of mega-cap tech names, it creates a fragility that investors instinctively sense. A single disappointing earnings report or valuation concern in the "Magnificent Seven" can trigger outsized index moves.

The contrarian interpretation is straightforward: when markets reach all-time highs amid extreme fear rather than euphoria, it often signals that gains have room to run. Fearful investors tend to underinvest, creating a "wall of worry" that actually supports further appreciation as that capital eventually rotates in.

The most dangerous market tops occur when optimism is universal and complacency reigns. We're nowhere near that right now.

Where Opportunity Meets Systematic Discipline

So what does a systematic investor do with this information? The temptation in uncertain times is to abandon discipline for market timing—to try to predict whether the Fed will cut in December, or when the next shutdown will hit, or which way tech stocks will break. But that's precisely backward.

This is when rules-based strategies earn their keep. When human emotion oscillates between fear and greed, when headlines dominate short-term price action, and when uncertainty clouds the fundamental picture, systematic approaches provide the ballast that prevents costly mistakes.

Consider what we know with reasonable confidence despite all the noise:

• Corporate fundamentals remain solid: Earnings growth is running at double digits, the strongest pace since 2021. While analysts worry about 2026 estimates, forward guidance hasn't shown material deterioration

• Valuations are elevated but not absurd: The S&P 500 trades around 21 times forward earnings—high by historical standards but not in bubble territory

• Economic growth remains positive: Despite shutdown effects, Q3 GDP tracked near 3.7%. Consumer spending continues, the labor market—while softening—hasn't cracked

• Inflation is declining, just slowly: The 3% annual rate is down from peaks above 9% in 2022. The trend is correct; the pace is frustrating

These factors support a constructive long-term view on equities, even as short-term volatility remains elevated. The key is matching portfolio positioning to both opportunity and risk—embracing equity exposure while maintaining enough discipline to rebalance when fear or greed reach extremes.

Strategy in Focus: AlphaFactory Protective

Given current market conditions—record highs meeting extreme fear, strong fundamentals facing policy uncertainty—one Surmount strategy that aligns particularly well is AlphaFactory Protective.

Here's why this strategy fits the current environment:

AlphaFactory Protective combines momentum and value factors with an intelligent volatility-based protective mechanism. The strategy focuses on a basket of 10 high-market-cap stocks from NASDAQ/NYSE alongside GLD (Gold ETF), using:

• Momentum scoring: 12-month return calculations to identify trending winners

• Value scoring: PEG ratios to avoid overpaying for growth

• Dynamic risk management: SPY realized volatility triggers that scale allocations

The protective overlay matters because of that extreme fear reading and elevated VIX:

• In low volatility environments: Full allocation to stocks to capture upside

• In moderate volatility: Mix of stocks and GLD to balance growth and protection

• In high volatility: Significant defensive positioning to preserve capital

This approach is particularly relevant right now because:

1. It acknowledges the opportunity in quality stocks with strong momentum and reasonable valuations

2. It respects the risk indicated by elevated fear and volatility measures

3. It removes emotion from the equation—no guessing about Fed decisions or shutdown impacts

The beauty of systematic approaches like AlphaFactory Protective is that they remove emotion from the equation. You're not lying awake at night wondering if you should have sold everything when the VIX hit 21, or kicking yourself for missing Wednesday's rally after the shutdown ended. You're following a predetermined set of rules that balance opportunity and risk across multiple market conditions.

In an environment where government shutdowns create data blackouts, the Fed is flying blind, and fear readings hit extremes at all-time highs, that emotional detachment is worth its weight in gold—which, incidentally, is up 64% over the past year as investors sought safety amid the chaos.

Looking Ahead: Navigating Uncertainty with Clarity

As we close out this extraordinary week and look toward year-end, a few guideposts emerge from the noise:

First: The January 30 funding deadline means shutdown uncertainty isn't resolved—it's merely postponed. Markets will need to price this risk repeatedly over coming months. That likely means elevated volatility persists, creating both opportunities and pitfalls.

Second: The Fed's December meeting on December 10-11 will be critical but potentially uninformative. Without October data and with November figures delayed, the decision will be more art than science. Powell will likely emphasize data-dependence while acknowledging the irony of having less data to depend on.

Third: Corporate earnings season largely validated 2025's market gains, but 2026 estimates matter more now. As companies provide forward guidance through year-end, watch for signs that the shutdown, labor market softness, or persistent inflation are crimping expectations. So far, that deterioration hasn't materialized—but in uncertain times, it's the inflection points that matter.

Finally: Remember that extreme fear at market highs is historically a contrarian bullish signal. When everyone is worried, it often means the worst-case scenarios are already priced in. The truly dangerous moments come when complacency reigns and valuations stretch to absurdity. We're not there yet.

For systematic investors, the path forward is the same as always:

• Maintain discipline

• Rebalance methodically

• Let rules guide decisions rather than emotions

Markets have weathered government shutdowns before (though none this long). They've navigated Fed uncertainty, missing data, and elevated volatility. What distinguishes successful long-term investors from the rest isn't the ability to predict these challenges—it's the discipline to stay the course through them.

The paradox of hitting all-time highs while fear hits extreme lows will resolve itself, one way or another. Either the fear will prove justified and markets will correct, or the fear will dissipate and the rally will continue. In either case, the systematic approach remains the same:

• Stay invested in quality assets

• Manage risk appropriately

• Trust that over long time horizons, fundamentals matter more than headlines

That's the real lesson from this remarkable week. Forty-three days of chaos couldn't break the market. What it did reveal is that even at the highest levels—in the halls of Congress, at the Federal Reserve, in corporate boardrooms—no one has perfect visibility on what's next.

With uncertainty running high and opportunity still present, that disciplined, systematic approach is more valuable than ever.

The information contained in this newsletter is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice. All investments carry risk, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Before making any investment decisions, consult with a qualified financial advisor to ensure any strategy aligns with your individual financial situation, goals, and risk tolerance

.